221B Baker St: The Master Detective Game –Swipe to Open
.
Step into the shoes of Sherlock Holmes in this classic mystery game as he travels around London collecting clues to over 20 scenarios. We’ve played this and it’s sister game, 221B Baker St: Sherlock Holmes the Time Machine, a couple times and with the simple mechanics, difficult puzzles, and a Clue like competitiveness to solve the mystery first; this game will be one we keep reaching for.
Run Time: 90 mins
BGG Rating: 6.0
2-6 players, Ages 10+
.
Likes: I’m a huge Clue fan, so themes of solving a mystery or riddles always attract me. This game specifically has a similar and simple way of moving and getting clues. It incredibly simple to learn how to play, but very hard to win. While this game is not as difficult as some of the Sherlock Holmes games I have played before, it still makes you use a lot of Holmesian deduction. Overall this game is light in complexity and can easily be played on a whim after dinner with gamers and non alike. .
Dislikes: I wish more of the scenarios were included in this base game. While there are over 100 cases in expansions, only 20 come in the box. There is an option to play in cooperative mode, and to us it fell flat. It is much more enjoyable to play against each other. It can get a bit monotonous if you are playing a 2-person game and you both are rolling poorly. Some of the components are cheap like the Scotland Yard cards are printed on hard cardstock, and aren’t cut out beautifully. .
Since we keep looking to be very critical of our collection and hone in on our favorite games to play at home or with friends, I think this one has a place in our collection. It’s more complex than Clue, but still has the pieces I love about games like this. .
#boardgames #boardgamereview #gamenight #boardgamedoctor #sherlockholmes #221bbakerst #mysterygame #deductiongame #boardgameart #toycollector #collection #boardgamegeek